I enjoyed Rogue One a lot as well! Tatiana Maslany is a wonderful actress and I think she would have brought something really interesting to Jyn, but I though Jones was fine.

I think that some hard core star wars fans around F!S really hated it, so whenever it comes up they will definitely show up with all the negativity. I am not a huge star wars nerd so I can't argue with people about whether it was true to star wars, or comment on production drama and the reshoots. I just liked the movie.