Oddly enough I came across an old list (from like a decade ago and based off of single performances) of my favourite comedians in a notebook when I was looking for paper to draw my pumpkin designs on... it's uhh, not exactly clear on how much I liked them unfortunately. (I know I got a few names wrong, since the comedy channel used to just list names and not say who's who) I used my old +/- rating system that's complete gibberish to me now.

Matt McCarthy
Pete Holmes
Jianne Geneafalo
Gilian Riner
Greg Fitzsimmons
Nick Kroll
Micheal Palersack
Matt O'Riely
Mark Maron
Ryan Dalton
Mo Mandel
Steven Wright
Peter Anthony

And my all time favourite, Jeremy Hotz!

(this very much probably does not help!)