IDK, I don't think she's that bad. I don't think she's going to win an Oscar or anything (Oscar gags aside), but I find her enthusiasm for the job and general joy whenever I see her in interviews/BTS stuff very endearing, and I think some of that affection for Karen has transferred into affection for Amy for me, more than the actual writing of the character. I realize that's a bit of a different beast than acting itself, but still, credit where it's due, that's Karen Gillan.