Well, that's not what your original point was saying. What you said earlier and the op were saying was quite different from 'bad decision they should have remembered protection' or whatever- you guys were saying that it's almost not understandable and you even said you don't think it's an accident and acting like it was a weakness in the book.

I also don't see what's wrong with what I said? Um I know that it's because they are all the same age, thanks? I was just pointing it out wondering why so angry about Tonks and Lupin and acting like it was so out there that this happened while accepting that that's what happened with everyone else. But it appears you have a problem with that too so never mind.

Actually, that's my question for you: why does it make you so upset?