OP here. Most of my friends like Supernatural so I get bombarded with it whenever I talk to them and whenever I am online. I want to like the show because what it's about is really cool (and because I could relate to my friends and immerse myself in a big, lively fandom) but I just can't get into it for some reason. And yes, every single person I have met who likes Supernatural (and it's a lot) are very attracted to one or both of them. That's why it feels like a big part of the show's ~allure~ is the "cute/hot guys".