I can relate. My best friend loves Supernatural. It's her favourite show and she watches it religiously. We used to share all our shows and talk about them all the time, but I just can't get into SPN. I really would like to and on the outside it looks like something that would be right up my alley. There's just something about it that doesn't click with me. I don't find the characters that attractive, but then there are plenty of other shows I like where I feel the same way (like Doctor Who). For me, it's probably the writing and storylines. Maybe it's gotten better, but I can't be arsed to sit through that many seasons to find out. I just tell my friend that I can't get into it and hope she stops insisting how "good" it is.