fandomsecrets | [ SECRET POST #2706 ]

[ SECRET POST #2706 ]

⌈ Secret Post #2706 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.

01.

__________________________________________________

02.

__________________________________________________

03.

__________________________________________________

04.

__________________________________________________

05.

__________________________________________________

06.

__________________________________________________

07.

__________________________________________________

08.

__________________________________________________

09.

__________________________________________________

10.

__________________________________________________

11.

__________________________________________________

12.

Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 04 pages, 079 secrets from Secret Submission Post #387.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

In the canon, Holmes is brilliant at understanding other people and communicating with them (cue The Veiled Lodger; The Hound&Laura Lyons; The Three Students; etc). He's anything but "flummoxed by normal conversation". He's polite (oh snap!), apologizes to others for fucking things up, tries to avoid intentionally endangering people for the sake of anything other than other people's lives (the only notable exception is Sir Henry Baskerville, in whose case SH hardly had any choice). And in contrast to the Warthropian toxic self-doubt/self-loathing, he assesses his experiences, acknowledges his mistakes, and moves on.

Haha, yes, I'm glad you wrote that, this is something that I suspected (I read a couple of the original ACD stories a long while back, so my view of these characters has since become skewed by the various popular interpretations). And it's also probably the reason I instictively hate BBC Sherlock ... I've ranted about this on F!S before, but nothing riles me more than hearing the "highly functioning sociopath" phrase. It's just so infinitely stupid, there's nothing admirable or enviable about lacking any complex emotion and a sociopath wouldn't care about helping people by solving crimes, duh.

Well, I don't know what a healthier relationship between Will and Warthrop would look like, but I can tell you that even after reading Isle, I was convinced that it was heading in that direction. There's a two-year gap between Isle and TFD and I wish Yancey didn't have to skip it due to the series being cancelled and all because it would've been interesting to see the immediate aftermath of what happens in Isle rather than skip into the future to see these characters firmly set out on a path to destruction.

But even in TFD there are glimpses of a reconciliation between them, except they are not written out explicitly as the text prefers to focus on the more negative aspects. I'm gonna be lazy here and post a link to tumblr because I've posted about one such moment before.

I do think that the BBC Sherlock flaunts the "sociopath" label in order to convince others that he doesn't experience complex emotions, but... yes. This series certainly has bugger all to do with the ACD Holmes, who is a waaay better (and more interesting, may I add) person than Sherlock. Plus, its plots are ludicrous nonsense of an astounding degree.

TBH I never thought there would be a happy ending. My working hypothesis during Isle was that Warthrop would get himself killed or that he'd go mad/turn into a monster (physically, that is). That would explain a lot about WH's being epically hung up on his love-hate for Warthrop and the man himself.

I just thought that the dealbreaker for me would be the source of the affection Will Henry displays towards the doctor - whether it is born of pure codependency more than anything else, or whether the healthier factors (i.e. the normal human mechanism of emotional bonding) prevail. Right now I'm trying to compare The Monstrumologist to Purple Hibiscus (which is a novel with a textbook depiction of a child-guardian relationship that is codependency first and everything else second), and I find the odds are in favour of the healthier factors. Because even as a child WH seems to manifest considerable emotional awareness that isn't really compatible with his being completely unable to understand his own feelings for PXW; because, in part, of the point you made in regards to TFD, where he is more or less an adult and still chooses to go back even despite his not being childishly enamoured with his mentor; and because the warmth of the friendship he describes isn't anything like the "affection" between the protagonist of Purple Hibiscus and her guardian (or any similar dynamics, for that matter).

I guess I'd vote for Warthrop unintentionally screwing up their chances of a more normal life. The changes in Will Henry that took place after Socotra scared him, and I think he, having the world's worst social skills, simply failed to do the necessary things to try and bring WH back. Which led to more estrangement on Will Henry's part and consequently to his becoming royally fucked in the head. Warthrop promised to never leave and to try and prevent WH from "drowning", and he tried, but he didn't understand the kind of attention and warmth WH would need.

Which must also have contributed to WH's exaggeration of the events, because he must've been extraordinarily bitter about this estrangement.

Actually, yes, I'm going to go ahead and headcanon TFD as being an epic exaggeration. And WH and the doctor totally had a heartfelt conversation before the doctor died, complete with crying and cursing and all that :')

I'm kind of satisfied there are two valid interpretations of the events. Maybe I should write a huge fix-it thing.

But either way, we can safely say that TFD!Will Henry wasn't actually a Kearns figure and that the book can be considered WH's attempt at scaring people away from the kind of life he led. Partially, I'm guessing, due to his post-Socotra fall-out with Warthrop. This leaves the TFD message intact (the worst monsters are still men) as well as gives us hope.

I guess I'd vote for Warthrop unintentionally screwing up their chances of a more normal life. The changes in Will Henry that took place after Socotra scared him, and I think he, having the world's worst social skills, simply failed to do the necessary things to try and bring WH back. Which led to more estrangement on Will Henry's part and consequently to his becoming royally fucked in the head. Warthrop promised to never leave and to try and prevent WH from "drowning", and he tried, but he didn't understand the kind of attention and warmth WH would need.

Yeah, but this is the part that gets unfortunately skipped over, so I concur with your conclusion that TFD is an exaggeration - I mean, how more unreliable can you get as a narrator than Will Henry who isn't even Will Henry - and the fact that no reconciliation was described doesn't mean that it couldn't happen.

TFD is the kind of book that is begging for a fix-it fic ;)

Yeah. Not!Will Henry has the reliability of a talking potato.

I picture it as a spectrum of understandings, with notable interpretations being "WH snapped under the pressure and everything went to shit" (pure TFD&probably what Yancey originally meant), "bad things happened and WH wrote TFD to give the impression that everything went to shit in order for others to avoid shit" (the most text-compatible interpretation, in my opinion), and "the whole of TFD is just a fake".

The second option certainly does imply the possibility of recovery they missed after Socotra. So, yes, there could be a healthier WH&PXW 'verse.

>TFD is the kind of book that is begging for a fix-it fic ;)

so it is. I may or may not end up being the first gen AO3 writer for TM.

You did reassure me a great deal.

Do feel free to talk to me whenever. If you want to discuss TM or anything else. You can ask me for my twitter username if you like, too (seeing as f!s and twitter are probably way better for fannish discussions than tumblr).

I don't have Twitter, but also feel free to talk to me anytime and anywhere ;) Even if you just want to check a canon fact, I've read the three books twice. Yeah, Tumblr has its drawbacks, but I've gotten used to it.

Anyway, I'm really glad that you enjoyed the books. And I'm glad your perception of TFD went from "this terrible inevitable doom" to basically "nah" :)

It's funny how the way to deal with TFD seems to be to try and find leeway for the characters not to end up quite so terribly rather than take it at face value, and yeah, this may be against Rick Yancey's original intention --- but, let's not forget he also wrote himself into the books as Will Henry's editor, thereby making the final authority on canon within canon his unreliable narrator, so ... there.

I've written a tiny gen fic for TM too, but I've also been working on a "fix-it" off and on for months now and I made that into Willinore, hopefully, I'll actually finish sometime.

Well, tbf I accept Yancey's original idea and I still think it was a very logical outcome. And if we are talking serious literary analysis, I would be considering the series from Yancey's point of view (thanks to the fact that my hang-ups about authorial intent are the size of California).

But as pure text compatibility goes, I do believe our headcanon is just as valid (if not more).

He could choose between treating his characters as living people and treating them as a means to his end, and he chose the former; and, though in so doing he enforced his message, he also sort of derailed it at the same time. Which was bound to happen, really. Living, well-developed characters have too many specifics to be a part of a universal philosophical idea. I mean, nobody tries (...I presume) to write a fix-it Metamorphosis thing. Samsa is a tool and all he does is serve his purpose. But WH&PXW aren't tools and they do more than convey a message; it is a weakness and simultaneously a strength of Yancey's work.

I wonder if anyone asked Yancey as to whether he thinks WH&PXW had any hope prior to TFD. Maybe I should.

>I've written a tiny gen fic for TM too, but I've also been working on a "fix-it" off and on for months now and I made that into Willinore, hopefully, I'll actually finish sometime.

did you, now?? Is it posted anywhere?

I'm not a shipper (which, considering this fandom's specifics, may just make me a sad outsider) and I've no interest in romance tropes, but I'll read shippy stuff as long as it has good characterizations. And I'll certainly read a fix-it.

I mean, nobody tries (...I presume) to write a fix-it Metamorphosis thing.

Lol, you know I think someone somewhere may have at least fantasized about Gregor's sister or whoever being nice to him and him turning slowly back to a human :D

But yeah, Will and the doctor are certainly the sort of characters that come alive and that's probably why readers have such an emotional response to them (rather than to just what their story represents).

Don't worry, I actually think the majority of TM fans don't ship the main characters, for what are probably obvious reasons, except that they haven't produced any fics - so you might be the first ;)

My fic is here. It's short and kind of meta-ish, but I'll put it on AO3 too, if just for the sake of motivating myself to finish the longer one.

Oh my God, this is brilliant. I laughed way too hard. I can imagine Warthrop being pretty good at writing but lolariously awful at giving writing advice. Or maybe he didn't even try - maybe the point of the whole exercise was to see how Will Henry would describe him in different ways. Because Warthrop is secretly dying of happiness that WH is writing about him :D

We'll see! I'm okay with being a forever-alone fan, anyway - it's virtually the story of my life, fannish and otherwise.

Yeah, well, The Monstrumologist fandom is all about laboring in darkness and obscurity, so welcome :)

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

[ SECRET POST #2706 ]

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist

Re: The Monstrumologist