ext_82219 (
shahni.livejournal.com) wrote in
fandomsecrets2008-02-13 12:01 pm
[ SECRET POST #404 ]
⌈ Secret Post #404 ⌋
Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.
1.
__________________________________________________
2.

__________________________________________________
3.

__________________________________________________
4.

__________________________________________________
5.

__________________________________________________
6.

__________________________________________________
7.

__________________________________________________
8.

__________________________________________________
9.

__________________________________________________
10.

__________________________________________________
11.

__________________________________________________
12.

__________________________________________________
13.

__________________________________________________
14.

__________________________________________________
15.

__________________________________________________
16.

__________________________________________________
17.

__________________________________________________
18.

__________________________________________________
19.

__________________________________________________
20.

__________________________________________________
21.

__________________________________________________
22.

__________________________________________________
23.

__________________________________________________
24.

__________________________________________________
25.

__________________________________________________
26.

__________________________________________________
27.

__________________________________________________
28.

__________________________________________________
29.
__________________________________________________
30.

__________________________________________________
31.

__________________________________________________
32.

__________________________________________________
33.

__________________________________________________
34.

__________________________________________________
35.

__________________________________________________
36.

__________________________________________________
37.

__________________________________________________
38.

__________________________________________________
39.

__________________________________________________
40.

__________________________________________________
41.

__________________________________________________
42.

__________________________________________________
43.

__________________________________________________
44.

__________________________________________________
45.

__________________________________________________
46.

__________________________________________________
47.

__________________________________________________
48.

__________________________________________________
49.

__________________________________________________
50.

__________________________________________________
51.

__________________________________________________
52.

__________________________________________________
53.

__________________________________________________
54.

__________________________________________________
55.

__________________________________________________
56.

__________________________________________________
57.

__________________________________________________
58.

__________________________________________________
59.

__________________________________________________
60.

__________________________________________________
61.

__________________________________________________
Notes:
- FANDOM'S MOST WANTED -- last day, people!!
Secrets Left to Post: 7 pages, 162 secrets from Secret Submission Post #058.
Secrets Not Posted: [1] broken links, [1] not!secrets, 0 not!fandom, [1] [2] [3] [4] too big, [1] wtf.
Next Secret Post: Tomorrow, Thursday, February 14th, 2008.
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

#6
Reason #104 why I disliked T&T: I kept sympathizing with the wrong characters.
6 OP
(Anonymous) 2008-02-14 12:52 am (UTC)(link)Honestly, I was totally on board with hating her guts until 3-5. I just... I feel really bad for anyone who has a crappy childhood. Dahlia's parents didn't love her, and she was separated from Iris -- even if she did actually orchestrate that, as she tells you, I get the feeling it was emotionally devastating. It doesn't excuse what she did at all; she caused a lot of pain, and she deserved to be brought to justice. But I still feel bad.
Also, if done wrong, hanging can be a terrible way to die. And actually, the end of 3-5 where Mia shuts her down really hit a bad chord for me. If you think about it, her soul's drifting out there, angry and alone and probably hurting. She doesn't get a chance for closure, and it seems like a miserable existence to me.
And I never really felt for Godot the way I think you were supposed to. He was a jerk to Phoenix for no apparent reason -- and in the end, it was a pretty crappy reason anyway. But the big thing is that he got a good woman killed just because he wanted to look like a hero. There is no reason all of 3-5 couldn't have been prevented if he'd just explained the situation. Even if he didn't tell Phoenix, he could have told Maya, and she could have handled it.
There are plenty of reasons to feel bad for Godot, and there are plenty of reasons to hate Dahlia. It just didn't work out that way for me, and it's a little annoying to watch the majority of fandom go "poor Godot" and "kill Dahlia with fire!" without seeing the grey in there.
Um, sorry. Had a lot to get off my chest, and ^that probably wouldn't fit on a secret ^_^;;
Re: 6 OP
But seriously, I felt the exact way. Exactly. Especially on this:
And actually, the end of 3-5 where Mia shuts her down really hit a bad chord for me. If you think about it, her soul's drifting out there, angry and alone and probably hurting. She doesn't get a chance for closure, and it seems like a miserable existence to me.
YES. And I understand that I'm probably alone on this, but I found that part to be unnecessarily cruel. Dahlia may have been a sociopath, but at least she let her victims rest in peace.
Re: 6 OP
It was cruel, and it was uncomfortable because the game intended for us to feel thrilled that the Big Bad got taken down. Dahlia had no right to do what she did. She needed to be stopped. But it just seemed to underscore the idea that even in death, no one was ever on her side.