[ SECRET POST #4048 ]

[case]

⌈ Secret Post #4048 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.

01.



__________________________________________________



02.
[Transformers]


__________________________________________________



03.
[Boku no Hero Academia]


__________________________________________________



04.
[Star Wars: The Last Jedi]


__________________________________________________




















05. [SPOILER for The Shape of Water]
[WARNING for gore and animal cruelty]



__________________________________________________



06. [SPOILER for Assassination Classroom]
[WARNING for abuse]



__________________________________________________



07. [WARNING for incest (and underage?)]

[Chronicles of Narnia, Peter/Susan]


__________________________________________________



08. [WARNING for discussion of sexual harrassment]


















Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 00 pages, 00 secrets from Secret Submission Post #579.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Comments

[fscom]

07. [WARNING for incest (and underage?)]
https://i.imgur.com/QgQEf5H.jpg
[Chronicles of Narnia, Peter/Susan]

[(Anonymous)]

What's happening in this scene?

[(Anonymous)]

They're being kind of parnental to Lucy, so it has a kind of married couple vibe.

[(Anonymous)]

OMG, yes. They totally look like mom and dad reacting to something their precious baby has done. I don't blame OP at all for their shippy thoughts.

[(Anonymous)]

Which scene is this?

Also, it's Narnia. The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe was pretty much set up to grow Pevensie sibling ships. The later books modified the premise enough to avoid repeating that. But Narnia fandom is known for the brother-sister ships.

[greghousesgf]

C.S. Lewis would turn over in his grave.

Are you sure?

[(Anonymous)]

Isn't it speculated that he was lovers with a woman he routinely introduced as his mother (not his actual mother, but the mother of a brother-in-arms from army training)?

pretty sure, yeah

[(Anonymous)]

Lewis 'adopted' the wife and sister of one of his friends that was killed while they were both serving in WWI because of a promise to watch over each other's families they'd both made to each other. The guy's wife and mother pretty much moved in with Lewis and lived with him from that point on. He's pretty brutally frank in his books that aren't the Narnia series (he even mentioned the habit of boys are boarding schools shagging each other and how the older ones would look over the new younger arrivals to decide who they wanted to make a play for) and he never mentioned anything else about the sister and mother. He did end up falling in love with and marrying a divorced woman from America when he was older however and when she died it absolutely gutted him to the point where he questioned his most core principles and beliefs (which he also wrote a very frank book about). I'm not surprised to hear people are looking for kinky backstory on Lewis but I will say I've never heard anything from what his contemporaries or that he said himself that says that's the right tree to bark up.

sa

[(Anonymous)]

bad typing, sorry. I was at work. 'Mother and sister' that should read. Lewis adopted his friend's mother and sister.

Re: pretty sure, yeah

[(Anonymous)]

The only kinky backstory on Lewis I'm aware of is that he wrote to a friend about having a spanking kink (during his college days), though I don't know if there's evidence he ever actually indulged it

Re: pretty sure, yeah

[(Anonymous)]

ayrt

George Sayer, who knew him, wrote a biography about him. He didn't think CS Lewis and Mrs. Jane Moore were lovers, but admitted there was a possibility. But after conversations with Mrs. Moore's daughter, Maureen, and the bedroom arrangements at The Kilns (the house, CS Lewis, his brother, Mrs. Moore, and Maureen lived in), he decided they were and included it in the introduction of a later edition of his biography. Mrs. Moore later suffered from dementia was moved into a home in the 1940s and died in 1951. CS Lewis didn't marry until 1956. Just because he doesn't mention it, doesn't mean it didn't happen. You have to remember the time and that she was 26 years his senior. I'm not saying any of that's absolute, but there is speculation.

[(Anonymous)]

I ended up shipping Caspian with Susan or Peter except that I hate what they did to Peter in Prince Caspian. I would read Caspian/Peter for the loyalty dynamic but there's so much dick measuring in the fics. If you get book Peter, you don't get the stuff from the movie that made them shippable.

[(Anonymous)]

The BBC versions of their dynamic are honestly, just as bad, because the dynamic between Pete and Su in the first movie is that they are being very "british" and trying to be "stiff upper lip" and "grown up" and take care of Ed and Lu. Thus, they turned into "mum and dad" for the foursome. It can be very easy to read that dynamic as romantic, even when it really isn't supposed to be!

Given the way the two argue, if they weren't related, they'd be horrible partners unless they managed to work heavily on their differences. Peter's over responsibility, pride and temper. Susan's vanity and need to be right and smart all the time. Together, they are rather oil and water and people do like that type of thing! (It's just not always my type of thing.)

[tabaqui]

Not sure what about this scene, in particular, but i ship it. And Lucy/Mr. Tumnus.

Not sure who i ship with Edmund, but he *does* get someone......
*ponders*

[(Anonymous)]

Caspian and Eustace are popular as slash ships for Edmund. Caspian especially for book fans? I ship that so bad. And then there's that guy from Horse and His Boy who comes off as pretty boyfriendy but tends to get left out of the options.

For het, Lucy is a popular choice. Also there's Jadis...the crush is essentially canon (and if you age him up you can do some interesting dark and kinky aus)

[tabaqui]

Heeee! Yes, but....she was so damn mean. And chilly.
I like the idea of Edmund and Shasta! That was my favorite book, out of all of them, as s kid, because i wanted a talking horse.

Caspian i can see, Eustace....eh. He's with Jill, anyway.

I need to rewatch those movies.....

[(Anonymous)]

Wasn't Shasta supposed to be like 13 though? Edmund came off as being quite a bit older than that in that book, maybe 20 or something. Fully adult if young adult anyway.

[tabaqui]

Well, they were all kids at first, i mean - Lucy was like eight or ten? And then i think the kids stepped up in age by a year or two....?

Of course, at the end of LW&W, they were adults, but when they came out of the wardrobe, they were kids again....

So i guess you pick your time.

[(Anonymous)]

DA

I don't think it was ever explicitly said, but the books I had with the official drawings approved by Lewis showed the four to be definitely in their late teens or early twenties.

And if you want to go by "rules" of knighthood, to be Edmund's squire/page, Edmund should have been at least 18 to train him and Shasta/Cor and Corin should have been around 13 or 14. 14 if he was a full squire, 13 if he was an older page. It depends on when Lune decided to foster him to the Narnian Court.

Not that Lewis ever really told us how that worked either given he knighted both Peter, Edmund and Caspian quite YOUNG.

As a point of reference, Peter was 28 and Lucy was 23 when they returned through the wardrobe to England. All of them should have been married! (Though I'm a Lucy/Aslan shipper. Magic. MAGIC does LOTS OF THINGS. He is canonically a shape shifter. He can be a human!)

[tabaqui]

Heeeeeee!

But that was in Narnia after they'd been there for years, yes? They went in as kids. And i have *zero* clue about timelines, but when they went *back*, it was ages and ages later and they were kids again.

So Either you can age Shasta up, or have them meet when they're all kids, or...you know...go kinky. Whatever floats your boat.

[(Anonymous)]

SA

LOL what floats my pegasus shaped boat is shipping Lucy with Aslan and err... creating OCs for everyone else.

I've got a sweet intelligent don't make her mad Grecian style Queen (The Kind and The Ruthless) for Edmund. A pirate Queen for Peter. And a bardic Prince of the Stars at Rest for Susan. In the real world, the Grecian Queen and the Bardic Prince are adopted siblings. The pirate Queen is a daughter of a professor that went to India and well, sometimes Aslan tears his soul in half to create himself a male persona that's a bit of a rich never do well adventurer type that's best friends with the Grecian Queen. It's err.. gotten out of hand. One day I will finish ONE of the stories and actually post them somewhere.

Viva la fandom!

[tabaqui]

Holy fuck. Yes. Yes *please*. Because I would read the fuck out of that! WOWOWOW!

[(Anonymous)]

AU crossover ship: Edmund/Sarah from Labyrinth.

They got a LOT of issues in common! Guilt over sibling betrayal, fierce redemption arcs, and being sexually awakened/compromised by their creepy-seductive, magical antagonist.....

[tabaqui]

Oooooh. That's a good one! Yes! Headcanon accepted.

[(Anonymous)]

I neeeeeed this now.