I liked both actually. For their similarities, and for their differences too. Movie V was so much more human and relatable, and it was delightful seeing a whole new idea of him, while keeping the core real.

Comic V was a scary ass mofo, and though I loved him too, I couldn't relate.

there was no way to directly translate the comic into film. It would have been crap. It needed to be altered, and I thought they did a great job. Was it Moore's version? No, but it wasn't a bad one either.

And to your point about the Evie/V thing; I have mixed feelings on that, so I don't entirely disagree.