Case (
case) wrote in
fandomsecrets2008-09-03 05:05 pm
[ SECRET POST #606 ]
⌈ Secret Post #607 ⌋
Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.
102.

__________________________________________________
103.

__________________________________________________
104. [repeat]
__________________________________________________
105.

__________________________________________________
106.

__________________________________________________
107.

__________________________________________________
108.

__________________________________________________
109.

__________________________________________________
110.

__________________________________________________
111.

__________________________________________________
112.

__________________________________________________
113.

__________________________________________________
114.

__________________________________________________
115.

__________________________________________________
116.

__________________________________________________
117.

__________________________________________________
118.

__________________________________________________
119.

__________________________________________________
120.

__________________________________________________
121.

__________________________________________________
122.

__________________________________________________
123.

__________________________________________________
124.

__________________________________________________
125.

[ I LOST THE GAME ]
__________________________________________________
126.

__________________________________________________
127.

__________________________________________________
128.

__________________________________________________
129.

__________________________________________________
130. [repeat]
__________________________________________________
131.

__________________________________________________
132.

__________________________________________________
133.

__________________________________________________
134.

__________________________________________________
135.

__________________________________________________
136.

__________________________________________________
137.

__________________________________________________
138.

__________________________________________________
139.

__________________________________________________
140.

__________________________________________________
141.

__________________________________________________
142.

__________________________________________________
143.

__________________________________________________
144. [repeat]
__________________________________________________
145. [repeat]
__________________________________________________
146. [repeat]
__________________________________________________
147.

__________________________________________________
148.

__________________________________________________
149.

__________________________________________________
150.

__________________________________________________
151.

__________________________________________________
152.

__________________________________________________
153.

__________________________________________________
154.

__________________________________________________
155.

__________________________________________________
156.

__________________________________________________
157.

__________________________________________________
158.

__________________________________________________
159.

__________________________________________________
160.

__________________________________________________
161.

__________________________________________________
162.

__________________________________________________
163.

__________________________________________________
164.

__________________________________________________
165.

__________________________________________________
166.

__________________________________________________
167.

__________________________________________________
168.

__________________________________________________
169.

__________________________________________________
170.

__________________________________________________
171.

__________________________________________________
172.

__________________________________________________
173.

__________________________________________________
174.

__________________________________________________
175.

__________________________________________________
176.

__________________________________________________
177.

__________________________________________________
178.

__________________________________________________
179.

__________________________________________________
180.

__________________________________________________
181.

__________________________________________________
182.

__________________________________________________
183.

__________________________________________________
184.

__________________________________________________
185.

__________________________________________________
186.

__________________________________________________
187.
__________________________________________________
188.

Notes:
Help our little city grow!
Secrets Left to Post: 09 pages, 307 secrets from Secret Submission Post #087.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 1 2 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 1 2 - too big ], [ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 - repeat ], [ 1 - lol ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Re: Not OP's tl;dr
I guess my problem is that Phoenix is such a thin filter. Until AJ, he's not a round character in the way that Edgeworth is, because there are simply not the same opportunities to see him. It's Phoenix that I sometimes find uninteresting, so I can't really grok why somebody would play just for him. Phoenix is awesome, he's my proxy, he's my buddy, but it's Edgeworth I find compelling enough to keep playing for.
Part of the problem is that the story of Phoenix's journey is simply not enough motivation for me. If you take Edgeworth's personality and his own motivations, backstory, etc out of it, you're just going to rescue Princess Peach, and that type of storyline frankly bores the shit out of me. Bitch can rescue her damn self.
same not OP anon
(Anonymous) 2008-09-04 08:28 am (UTC)(link)To each their own. Can I help it if I like vanilla?
Not that I really see Phoenix as 'vanilla' myself, obviously. His moral naivety paired to his practicality, the more confident front he plays over his insecurities and a nearly insane desire to please others... Actually, I love learning things about him through interaction with the environment. He is the player proxy, but unlike, say, Link [whom I also like in his various incarnations XD], he does have a distinct voice of his own. It may be true that we never really have much of an opportunity to see him outside the work environment-- but, he's grown on me to the point where I would be interested in seeing the other aspects of his life.
Edgeworth... I dunno, I simply failed to make a connection with him. I think that may be part of my problem-- he feels a little unconnected to me, whether he's just keeping to himself (the way I see him in one) or absorbed in himself (the way I see him in two). Phoenix is real to me. Edgeworth is just some ideal stuck in Phoenix's head that doesn't match the reality.
And AJ. Oh dear, the love/hate relationship I have with that game. But I guess I won't tl;dr about it here :)
But essentially, it seems we shall always differ on this matter of taste. I just wanted to point out to you that people with opinions such as mine do exist, and we like Ace Attorney just fine XD
Re: same not OP anon
It is true that there is a lot to learn about Phoenix through playing, but it's still a little light for my tastes. It may be, too, that I've played the games too damn much, so I've internalized all that stuff about Phoenix. It's not that I'm not interested in him, either- there's just more interesting stuff to look at.
Oh god, let's just not even start on AJ. We'd be here until the Rapture.
...Would anon be interested in writing a counterpoint essay about this type of stuff, assuming I ever get around to actually writing an essay about it like I'm threatening?
Re: same not OP anon
(Anonymous) 2008-09-05 01:35 am (UTC)(link)I would probably give it a shot, since I'm the type of person who likes to type these kinds of things out (...as if you couldn't tell). It helps me work things out for my own benefit, at the very least.
Only problem is with the anon-ness I am so fond of hiding behind. I could probably give you a poke on AIM with the screenname I use for hanging out in the empty kink meme chatroom, if you'd like a way to get in direct touch with me.
Re: same not OP anon
My AIM is a little sketch right now, but we can try it out. You can also just email me at mcangmar [at] gmail [dot] com.