[ SECRET POST #2400 ]

[case]

⌈ Secret Post #2400 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.

01.


__________________________________________________



02.
[The Silmarillion]


__________________________________________________



03.
[Fire Emblem: Awakening]


__________________________________________________



04.
[Almost Human]


__________________________________________________



05.
[Gundam Wing and True Blood]


__________________________________________________



06.
[NCIS: LA]


__________________________________________________



07.
[Final Fantasy VII Compilation]


__________________________________________________



08.
[Tom Hiddleston/Loki]


__________________________________________________



09.
[Scott & Bailey]


__________________________________________________



10.
[Pokemon, Mondo/Domino]


__________________________________________________



11.
[Merlin]


__________________________________________________



12.
[Chris Colfer]


__________________________________________________


13.
[Danny Phantom]


__________________________________________________



14.
[Twin Peaks]














Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 03 pages, 064 secrets from Secret Submission Post #343.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 1 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Another Man's Cage is what made me first fall in love with Caranthir, I have to admit: headcanon to the max, but I love the thought that he has some mild/underdeveloped form of elven telepathy that makes him act so weird and unfriendly towards people who aren't his family and know how to handle all the Caranthir brand of strangeness. Though yes, little!Celegorm in that fic is pretty much how I imagine him too.

What, there were no taxes in heaven Valinor?

Probably not, but you can bet that by the first anniversary of his death the Halls of Mandos had a whole Inland Revenue/IRS division founded and set up by C. Feanorion. How dead elves pay taxes I'm not sure, but if anyone could figure it out then it could be Caranthir, and there's no escaping him.

...This is my thing about Eol. Celegorm is a dick, Curufin is nasty piece of work and both are horrible, unpleasant, murderous villains and there's no denying any of that even by fans of the sons of Feanor........ but the only (semi) canonical act of rape by an Elf in any of Tolkien's works is carried out by Eol, and he doesn't get even a fraction of a hate that the three Cs tend to. I have no problems with people hating on the Feanorians - deservedly so, for C3 & C5 - but the way that Eol just oozes under people's radars confounds me: people call Celegorm a rapist and seem to forget that the canon (semi) rapist even exists.

[(Anonymous)]

Caranthir's telepathy is certainly one of the most interesting interpretations I've found in fandom... when it works it really works. It gives a cool, tragic spin on what could become of his relations with Men later in life. I'd like Caranthir regardless, though, misanthropic curmudgeon that he was. I'd pay his taxes :D

Right? I think people cling rather heavily to that one text where Tolkien wrote that Aredhel was not "wholly unwilling", but all that means to me is that she managed to develop feelings for Eol after spending so much time in Nan Elmoth. Doesn't change the fact that he used entrapment and trickery to keep her there, to say nothing of all his creepy, abusive, murderous antics as husband and father. While the Feanorians commit mass atrocities on a grand scale appropriate for "villains" in this kind of epic story, Eol's actions represent a shockingly banal kind of evil that gets under my skin so much more. For an Elf, he seems more like someone you might meet in real life than, say, Feanor.

[(Anonymous)]

Phew, doesn't it just - I think my favourite part of this bit of 'what if' comes when you remember that the Men who betrayed the Union of Maedhros were sworn to Caranthir, and you can imagine him torturing himself over why he hadn't been able to pick that up. Like Ol' Broody needs yet another reason to sit in a dark corner and brood, but...

There was actually an excellent bit of meta over on Tumblr about this recently, and I wish I could remember the link... basically it was talking about all the changes Tolkien made to his treatises on Laws and Customs of the Eldar and whether or not Elves can actually rape/be raped. He seemed to change his mind towards 'yes' later on in life and I wonder if the 'not wholly unwilling' passage in the published Silmarillion is a holdover from the earlier days and/or Christopher Tolkien hedging his bets and not being 100% sure what his father's final decision was. Regardless, as it's written I believe that Eol Stokholmed the hell out of her: he's pretty much a textbook elven version of a man who kidnaps a woman, keeps her in a dark basement, gets her pregnant and so messes with her mind in hundreds of little ways that she stays in his house even when she has opportunities to escape: if Maeglin hadn't convinced Aredhel that they needed to get the hell out I'm sure she would have stayed right where she was in Nan Elmoth, but from the speed at which she's convinced and then determined to get herself and her son away from Eol there's no doubt that that's the last place she wants to be. I think you've got a really excellent point on the banality of evil that we see in Eol, though: 'genius creates limitless power source; massacres hundreds; is cursed by the gods' isn't a headline we see in the papers all that often, whereas what Eol did is frighteningly commonplace when you remove the pointy ears and the enchanted forest.

[(Anonymous)]

And you have to wonder, did Caranthir's experience with Haleth and her people influence his views on Men, leading to his later decision to throw his lot in with the Easterlings? See, there's just so much more to Caranthir, he was never in the spotlight but Tolkien still managed to toss in these little things. A two-dimensional bit player villain he ain't.

You know, Tolkien changed his mind about this and that so many times that I rather think even if he had lived to see The Silmarillion published, it still wouldn't have been the definitive version. But The Silmarillion itself is closer to a fictional historical anthology than it is a story anyway. Just like with history, there are numerous, even conflicting versions of the same accounts and people who just can't agree on these things (you can't tell me the Feanorian apologists aren't just as intense as actual historical apologists).

No disagreement on Eol from me, for sure. And while I'd never wish that fate on anyone, I think it's particularly tragic that it happened to Aredhel who was such a free spirit and had just escaped a life of loose imprisonment in her brother's kingdom. It's my headcanon that Aredhel went to Gondolin for Idril's sake, and it was Idril who later convinced her to leave and find freedom. After Aredhel's death, Idril might have harbored guilt about her involvement, and tried to atone by being extra kind to Maeglin -- leading him to get the wrong idea.