[ SECRET POST #5967 ]

[case]

⌈ Secret Post #5967 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.


01.



__________________________________________________



02.



__________________________________________________



03.



__________________________________________________



04.



__________________________________________________



05.



__________________________________________________



06.



__________________________________________________



07.
























Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 02 pages, 28 secrets from Secret Submission Post #853.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Comments

Re: Inspired by 6 - drama bombs

[(Anonymous)]

Just because he has good intentions doesn’t make him “completely in the right” though. That’s one of the reasons why people still think he’s the villain. It’s not always about your intentions at the start, it’s about the actions you take along the way. Cap went way too far and made so much shit worse. Nobody looks good in this awful movie, or the atrocious comics it’s based on, because they’re all taking the worst measures possible to achieve their ends, and acting way stupider than they usually would for transparent plot reasons like drama. They all have understandable goals on paper, at least at the start. But they fuck everything up, and then needlessly endanger people more by having their stupid airport fight. And then Steve and Bucky have their dumb fight with Tony. Who’s just learned something awful and is understandably upset. But that’s still not an excuse for attacking someone he just acknowledged was under mind control. And then Cap and Bucky go way too far in the fight, and Bucky almost beheads him. Which was completely avoidable, and goes so far past the “self-defense” excuse because of how far out of his way he went to get that close to killing him.

So a terrible showing all around from start to finish. And Cap is just as bad as Tony in it. No matter if the accords were trustworthy, or whether Bucky deserved to get punished for crimes he didn’t willingly commit(obviously not), Cap does so many shitty actions. So no, based on all the things he did or almost did, he’s not “completely in the right”, just because his motives were understandable and sympathetic.

Re: Inspired by 6 - drama bombs

[(Anonymous)]

How did his actions make ANYTHING worse? He's the one who discovered the plot to release the bad super soldiers. He's the one who focused on stopping them. He stopped an innocent man from being used by two different bad guys (Zemo and Ross) to commit even more crimes. I can't think of a single thing Steve does that makes anything worse. STARK started the airport fight. Steve and Bucky were trying to stop the bad guy, Stark showed up at the airport with a kidnapped teenager in direct violation of the accords to START a super powered fight. Steve just tried to get on a goddamned plane.

Sure, Stark understandably upset, but you don't MURDER people. That's why we have a justice system. And Stark's whole position in this movie was to support even MORE rules and regulations to prevent JUST THIS INSTANCE; though it's quite obvious as the plot moves along that Stark in reality intended them to be rules for everyone but him. He ignores his own arguments and position every time he's ever restricted in his own desires. His actions make A LOT of things worse (lying to his teammates, lying to a minor's guardian, kidnapping a minor, starting a super powered fight in a public area against the accords he signed, trying to murder a POW, general hypocrisy).

Steve and Bucky go to far in the fight? Again, Stark started the fight. He didn't even go after Bucky first; he sucker punched Steve. When he goes after Bucky, Steve yells at Bucky to run. Bucky runs, he doesn't attack Stark. Steve only defends to keep Stark away from Bucky. Bucky only turns around to attack when STARK seriously threatens Steve. And even then, Bucky never gets anywhere near to beheading Stark. He obviously only goes to incapacitate by targeting his arc reactor. And Stark blows his ARM OFF. Steve then gets "understandably upset" and beats the crap out of Tony, but guess what? He doesn't try to kill him. He achieves Bucky's goal of destroying the arc reactor so that Stark can't attack them anymore and then. They LEAVE. They don't beat him up more. They don't try to kill him. They incapacitate so they can STOP FIGHTING. Stark was the aggressor in EVERY interaction.

You haven't provided any shitty actions on Cap's part. Just "went to far" with no details, leading me to believe you don't have any. On the other hand, I have provided several instances of where Stark was objectively, both in terms of real life morality and by the rules of the movie, completely in the wrong.

Steve was completely right.