[ SECRET POST #2204 ]

[case]

⌈ Secret Post #2204 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.

01.


__________________________________________________



02.


__________________________________________________



03.


__________________________________________________



04.


__________________________________________________



05.


__________________________________________________



06.


__________________________________________________



07.


__________________________________________________



08.


__________________________________________________



09.


__________________________________________________



10.


__________________________________________________



11.


__________________________________________________



12.


__________________________________________________



13.


__________________________________________________



14.


__________________________________________________



15.


__________________________________________________



16.


__________________________________________________



17.


__________________________________________________



18.


__________________________________________________



19.


__________________________________________________



20.


__________________________________________________



21.


__________________________________________________



22.


__________________________________________________








Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 04 pages, 091 secrets from Secret Submission Post #315.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 1 - not!secrets ], [ 1 - not!fandom ], [ 1 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Hm, that's a good point. I guess I'd have been more bothered if it had actually changed Kazran into someone else than what actually happened, which was...he was basically the same, just with another set of issues and perfectly aware of what happened to him, and he ultimately changed more in real time than via memories.

I suppose the scenario definitely has the potential to be deeeeeeeeply creepy if the specifics were tweaked a bit though. I mean, from later in the season...I've heard some people going "omg the Doctor and the Ponds are such selfish jerks they should've tried to rescue bb!Melody" and I'm like WHAT WHAT WHAT NO THEY SHOULDN'T HAVE River would have flipped five hundred lids if they decided to wipe out her entire timeline!!! Not to mention Ten kinda promised her on her deathbed not to rewrite a single line of her life...

And now that's starting to make me remember how when it was revealed that the Doctor/River timelines were actually inverse-parallel, not just out of order, it conveniently avoided the fact that it would be almost subconscious-level easy for River to manipulate and groom him into becoming exactly who she remembers given that he's guilt-trapped into never taking the "hightail it the fuck out this relationship" emergency option after what happened in the Library. Huh. Funny how a little difference in situational context and specific details can make a concept SO different...

[tenlittlebullets]

It just seems like a giant moral line in the sand that the show skipped merrily over without more than a passing nod to how dodgy it was--the whole "you will have empathy whether you want to or not," and using time travel to rewrite someone's whole life and make them into the person you want them to be because you don't like the person they are. Or because the person they are is inconvenient to you--jesus, the implications of that are spine-chilling. The original Christmas Carol was very much "this is your life, these are your choices, this is the effect they're having and the effect they will have if you don't change course," and ultimately the choice lands right in Scrooge's lap; in Moffat's version Kazran doesn't have anything like that kind of agency, the Doctor just decides to make him a better person and give him a different set of life experiences to work with, and while this is acknowledged to be a pretty extreme measure, it's never really dealt with as an incredibly creepy violation of who Kazran is as a person.

Like you said, the parallels with River are obvious, but why are the situations reversed in that case? Just because the Doctor likes her? Or because personally rewriting someone's life with foreknowledge of how you're changing them, even to erase a tragedy, is an inherently terrible thing to do, and the fact that the Silence custom-tailored River into the person they wanted is what makes them the bad guys? I have similar issues with Donna's mindwipe--it's not that inflicting terrible creepypasta on beloved characters is inappropriate for a kids' show, the baddies do it all the time, but if you're going to make the Doctor do it, the full creepy terribleness needs to be dealt with and it needs to be established as 5000% necessary in the plot. The one thing you can't do is treat it lightly and try to gloss it over.

(Are the Doctor and River really reverse-parallel? At some point River mentions they are, but that seems to be a general trend rather than them meeting in strictly reverse order. In any case, Moffat does seem to be aware of the free will issues with this one, which is why they're so strict about the diaries and Eleven is so upset about the predestination paradoxes in Angels Take Manhattan. They know, in a general sense, that they're going to be important to each other, but avoiding spoilers means that whatever happens when they meet isn't "scripted" by foreknowledge and they can make their own decisions.)

[(Anonymous)]

Hm...I see what you mean, but I think the reason I can't see the big line in the sand is that I can't see why doing a "this is your life, these are your choices", as you say, would somehow be valid to do to old!Kazran but not valid to go back and do to young!Kazran. Young!Kazran is just as much a person as old!Kazran. If episode had instead introduced us to young!Kazran going about in real time and then meeting the Doctor and then was shown that he could become this "hypothetical" (from his perspective) old man who's so awful that he'd let a spaceship full of people die because he couldn't be bothered, I can't see how it would be a violation of "who Kazran is as a person" if young!Kazran went "hell no I don't want to become him!"

And if the Doctor did it to old!Kazran, it's also not THAT different from rewriting even-older!Kazran. Which, again, doesn't exactly fix those grey areas, I just don't think they're all that different from anything involving time travel. Or that bug-thing from Turn Left. Or even not involving time travel at all -- who's to say you're not totally rewriting a hypothetical future version of yourself right at this moment?

It's not identical of course: there's the fact that the Doctor has specific foreknowledge, yeah, which does put a different spin on it, but...I dunno what exactly the alternative was. It's not like he had time to sit around wheedling old!Kazran into being better, or could erase his memories of old!Kazran and fling himself into the past blindly with the expectation that he'd accidentally somehow make Kazran better.

The issue, for me, is that the portrayal of how that kind of thing works, especially with Kazran remembering both sets of memories, kind of randomly breaks a bunch of pre-established rules and norms about how time travel works in the Whoniverse. But that's Moffat for you. *bangs head against wall repeated re: Angels Take Manhattan*

[tenlittlebullets]

Except "nebulous future!Kazran" and "future!Kazran whom the Doctor has already met" are different, because the show goes to great pains to establish that foreknowledge of events, or going through events in your own timestream, makes them real in a way that glimpses of possible futures aren't. Meeting young!Kazran and asking him to look at his life, look at his choices, via some magic device that shows you possible futures but doesn't fix any of them in reality, would be way different from meeting older!Kazran and then going back in time just to manipulate younger!Kazran into choosing a future whereby that guy will never have existed.

It's like... it's like "The Girl Who Waited," which is already dark as all hell because it takes that scenario seriously instead of trying to pass it off as heartwarming. The only reason it's not even darker is because older!Amy agrees to give her younger self a shot at a better life than she had, and when it becomes clear that the two Amys can't coexist, she ultimately tries to comfort Rory and the Doctor by agreeing to sacrifice herself so they're not straight-up murdering her. If it hadn't been voluntary, it would've strayed into "way too fucked-up to be on Doctor Who" territory. A Christmas Carol gives me the raging heebie-jeebies because it's basically TGWW with older!Amy kicking and screaming the whole time, and it's trying to pretend it isn't.