ext_33427 (
degrees.livejournal.com) wrote in
fandomsecrets2007-12-14 04:45 pm
[ SECRET POST #343 ]
⌈ Secret Post #343 ⌋
Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.
1.

__________________________________________________
2.

__________________________________________________
3.

__________________________________________________
4.

__________________________________________________
5.

__________________________________________________
6.

__________________________________________________
7.

__________________________________________________
8.

__________________________________________________
9.

__________________________________________________
10.

__________________________________________________
11.

__________________________________________________
12.

__________________________________________________
13.

__________________________________________________
14.

__________________________________________________
15.

__________________________________________________
16.

__________________________________________________
17.

__________________________________________________
18.

__________________________________________________
19.

__________________________________________________
20.

__________________________________________________
21.

__________________________________________________
22.

__________________________________________________
23. [ removed to keep LJ from banning me ]
__________________________________________________
24.

__________________________________________________
25.

__________________________________________________
26.

__________________________________________________
27. [ removed to keep LJ from banning me ]
__________________________________________________
28.

__________________________________________________
29.

__________________________________________________
30.

__________________________________________________
31.

__________________________________________________
32.

__________________________________________________
33.

__________________________________________________
34.

__________________________________________________
35.

__________________________________________________
36.

__________________________________________________
37.

__________________________________________________
38.

__________________________________________________
39.

__________________________________________________
40.

__________________________________________________
41. [ removed to keep LJ from banning me ]
__________________________________________________
42.

__________________________________________________
43.

__________________________________________________
44.

__________________________________________________
45.

__________________________________________________
46.

__________________________________________________
47.

__________________________________________________
48.

__________________________________________________
Notes:
If I may direct your attention to this poll HERE
EDIT: I removed a few secrets because it was just brought to my attention (I have a crappy memory) that people are being banned for being flagged for this kind of stuff. SORRY. D:
Secrets Left to Post: 00 pages, 00 secrets from Secret Submission Post #049.
Secrets Not Posted: 0 broken links, [ 1 2 ] not!secrets, 0 not!fandom [ 1 ] secret revisted/link to fanfiction.
Next Secret Post: Tomorrow, Saturday, December 15th, 2007.
Current Secret Submission Post:
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Re: 44
When he destroyed Akzeriuth, yes, he needed people to make sure he took responsibility for what he'd done, but after that they acted like he was a terrible human who didn't deserve a second chance, even when he was desperately trying to change. Tear told him that she didn't buy his routine for a moment and she would judge him every damn step of the way. He didn't need to be told he was a terrible human being -- he already believed that! He wasn't "learning the hard way", he was being kicked when he was down and told that they'd kick him some more every time he tried to get back up.
Luke's friends are dicks to him. The end.
Re: 44
(Anonymous) 2007-12-15 06:01 am (UTC)(link)Everyone else in the group was on a mission to SAVE the people of Akzeriuth. For them the only people that mattered were the citizens who were dying rather horrible deaths. Why would they want to deal with a brat who snapped at every piece of advice given to them? People needing saving > brat anyday, in my books. No one tried to help him that ENTIRE time BEFORE Akzeriuth, REALLY? I think you've got a screw loose. They all mentioned Luke's attitude to him several times and warned him that he better shape up. It was his decision to ignore their warning.
He DIDN'T deserve another chance. He kept whining that it wasn't his fault. Why should anyone console a person claiming it wasn't their fault when he had to share at least partial blame? Anyone else would've been beside themselves with grief over this crime but all Luke could say was "It's not my fault, Van was...not my fault...Master Van, Master Van, Master Van". They would've been by his side the entire time if he just admitted that he was in the wrong. But NOPE. Luke hadn't learned his lesson yet. Tear didn't say she didn't buy his routine for a minute. She said she would watch over him to make sure his words would finally be put into action.
Why don't you play the game and actually pay attention to what the OTHER characters are doing for a change? Luke is a good character who goes from one extreme to the other before finally finding a balance but you wouldn't know that would you?
Re: 44
No one should hug Luke instead of making him take responsibility for the lives lost.
No one should have told him Akzeriuth is not his fault.
There are about five minutes during which Luke convinces himself that it isn't his fault. During this time, his friends abandoned him. Good. They should have, if he was that deluded.
I am not talking about this time. Okay? Can you grasp that? Is that okay?
I am talking about a period shortly after this time.
In this period, Luke knew that it was his fault, that he had failed utterly, that he was responsible.
He swore to try and become a better person.
Tear told him she didn't think he could ever be a better person and that she would judge him every step of the way. Many of his "friends" sneered at him and reminded him of his failures every time he might have felt better about himself. He was trying to grow as a character and they are trying to put him in a box.
This is why they are dicks.
This doesn't mean that they are evil or that *LAWL* I am ignoring them. Frankly, if I joined the fandom, I'd probably ignore Luke entirely. I'm way more interested in Anise, Peony, Guy, Natalia, Asch, etc. But that doesn't mean they don't treat Luke like crap.
Intelligent and rational people are capable of making the distinction that sometimes awesome characters act like dicks.
Maybe that will keep you from constructing straw men for twelve seconds? Too much to hope for?