fandomsecrets | [ SECRET POST #2615 ]

⌈ Secret Post #2615 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.

01.

__________________________________________________

02.

__________________________________________________

03.

__________________________________________________

04.

__________________________________________________

05.

__________________________________________________

06.

__________________________________________________

07.

__________________________________________________

08. [repeat]

__________________________________________________

09.

__________________________________________________

10.

__________________________________________________

11.

__________________________________________________

Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 03 pages, 074 secrets from Secret Submission Post #374.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

I. Doyle would murder the killer (given there is one), go into deep shock, pointlessly risk his life (twice), weep like the world's about to end, and do stupid heartbreaking little things like trying to cover Bell's body with his coat. That's the way it really happened in the canon source (shbfkfgbmngdfh). In the long term, though, I think he'd move on with his life, marry someone (Louisa Hawkins, I imagine), and get kids. And in many regards he would be happy. But he'd never forget Bell's death, and it would always be a source of terrible anguish for him.

If we are talking about Bell's actual death (1911), Doyle would probably react the same way, but his grief would be much more bearable, and he would remember the good things, too. And ultimately, he'd be much more happy than if Bell were killed by Cream (or somebody else).

Bell? Bell would bloody break. He'd never be happy again, ever. He'd go on working on the cases alone, invariably gloomy and pessimistic, and die knowing that he did what had to be done. But he'd never recover. It isn't like Bell to be suicidal, so he wouldn't kill himself (not unless he believed that Doyle's death was his fault, which, admittedly, is kind of likely in the context of the series).

II. Well, we've seen how Watson reacted to Holmes's "death". He moved on and had a normal married life and was fine in many regards. I don't think Holmes's demise was unbearable to Watson or that it was emotionally breaking him - he grieved, yes, he grieved a lot, but it was not a morbid kind of grief. Maybe a little deeper than it's entirely healthy, but not so as for Watson to be unable to endure it.

He'd always cherish his memories of Holmes, always remember him, and always defend his honour if such a necessity should arise (see EMPT). Holmes would be like his metaphorical guardian angel.

Holmes? I'm pretty sure he'd commit suicide. I can't imagine Holmes living without Watson.

III. Peter Grant would be traumatized for the rest of his life by Nightingale's death. It wouldn't be unbearable grief or anything like that, but he'd flinch and feel his blood run a little colder every time he'd remember it.

In theory, he'd able to move on and have a normal life. But in practice, he'd have the Folly to take care of, and I imagine that ultimately, he'd just become the second Nightingale.

Or maybe he'd become a genius loci. I feel like it would be the best solution for him.

Nightingale? He'd probably be suicidal, but I'm not sure he would actually commit suicide. He might pull himself together and soldier on. It wouldn't end well, though.

Edited (how do u spell) 2014-03-01 23:37 (UTC)

Like Doc Daneeka&Yossarian. Brotp forever. And yet I'm pretty sure Yossarian would be just like "aw what a pity, but I don't care", and Doc Daneeka would just say something rueful that would be lost in his stream-of-consciousness endless list of complaints.

Well, OK, Yossarian would drink to Doc's memory. And then he'd go and fuck Nurse Duckett. And that's it.

My brotps are strange.

Edited 2014-03-01 23:43 (UTC)

I was secretly kinda thinking the same about Holmes' reaction, but I know that my mind tends to get a bit too sappy and melodramatic in my thinking about this kind of thing so I kinda second-guessed myself.

(Although I think that if Watson died while Holmes was in the middle of a case, he'd still finish the case first.)

I agree with that (especially in the light of our discussion above). Holmes's a professional who's obsessed with his work. He'd definitely finish the case.

I'm not sure ACD himself would make Holmes commit suicide, but then again, I also think that a major character death in the context of this series is such an unimaginable thing that there is no guessing the would-be authorial intent. And from the looks of it, Holmes wouldn't be able to go on after Watson's death. And I seriously doubt he'd willingly choose the gallows after killing Evans.

ETA: isn't it a little eerie how we always agree on things and talk to each other? I may just be your fictional twin or something along the lines of William Wilson.

Edited 2014-03-02 00:19 (UTC)

Well, we mostly talk about either Sherlock Holmes or writing and literature in general, so that's sorta a narrow basis ;) But one thing we definitely do disagree on is that I am totally content with death of the author.

ETA: oh man, now I want fic where Watson's death IS the case that Holmes has to investigate first.

Edited 2014-03-02 00:49 (UTC)

I may write it, actually, once I'm done with my Rivers fic. Because it's an awesome idea.

DO IT. DOOOOOOOOO IT! *throws encouragement cookies*

[ SECRET POST #2615 ]

Re: How do you think the members of your OTPs or brOTPs would react to the other's death?

it is it weird that I have brotps who wouldn't give a damn

Re: How do you think the members of your OTPs or brOTPs would react to the other's death?

Re: How do you think the members of your OTPs or brOTPs would react to the other's death?

Re: How do you think the members of your OTPs or brOTPs would react to the other's death?

Re: How do you think the members of your OTPs or brOTPs would react to the other's death?

Re: How do you think the members of your OTPs or brOTPs would react to the other's death?