fandomsecrets | [ SECRET POST #3111 ]

[ SECRET POST #3111 ]

⌈ Secret Post #3111 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.

01.

__________________________________________________

02.

__________________________________________________

03.

__________________________________________________

04.

__________________________________________________

05.

__________________________________________________

06.

__________________________________________________

07.

__________________________________________________

08.

__________________________________________________

09.

[Peaky Blinders - not a repeat]

__________________________________________________

10.

Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 03 pages, 067 secrets from Secret Submission Post #445.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Yeah, but I'm telling you that doesn't really reflect the comics, at least not at the moment. There's a distinction to be made, and if the only person making that distinction has to be me then so be it, but I'm never not going to tell people don't mistake the movies for the comics.

Well, as exclusively a movie watcher, DC will always be the "WE MUST BE DARK AND DEPRESSING" until they release something fun. Maybe Suicide Squad will be fun but I've yet to see the comic-con trailer for that.

Again, that's WB, not DC.

Not holding out too much hope for Suicide Squad, but hell I may be surprised, given that Assault on Arkham was pretty fun.

They have a big DC logo at the beginning of every movie. Therefore, they are DC to me.

That's nice, but you're wrong.

It's WB using DC characters. And WB doesn't actually know how to make a superhero movie. That is my entire point.

Edited 2015-07-11 20:56 (UTC)

From your perspective, DC is an full of darkness and light and kittens and balloons.

From MY perspective, DC is full of darkness (both story wise and color wise). That isn't a bad thing necessarily, but to me it can make the movies a chore to watch.

I KNOW THAT!

What I am trying to tell you is that you shouldn't let the movies reflect on the comics because WB and DC have very different approaches to the characters. I don't even consider the movies to be part of DC, nor do I feel they reflect on DC as a whole. I'm not telling you your experience is wrong. I'm just trying to give you some context. But you're just repeating your argument as if I'd never actually said anything and I'm just wasting my time aren't I.

I don't care about DC on the comics side. And telling me that DC comics are fun and more complex doesn't effect me (or my opinion) in any way.

So, yes, it is a waste of time to tell me that "No, DC isn't all dark because this portion of DC that you will never see isn't dark."

Also, I enjoy many of DC's movies. The Dark Knight trilogy is amazing. And I expect I will enjoy at least Batman's portion of this movie. Doesn't make them not dark.

I fucking give up.

I am pretty sure kaijin appreciates that lol

Anyone would be appreciative of Deaftool shutting the fuck up.

dethtoll, I think what kaijin is trying to get across to you is that the comics DON'T MATTER to many movie watchers. they don't have any exposure to or knowledge of the recent comics.

therefore, their only exposure to "DC", their only knowledge of what DC comics are like, is the association with the films. which are still stuck in the grimdark edginess of the 90s.

i mean, it's fine that you don't consider the movies to be a part of DC (a wise move tbh, that last Superman film was a slog to get through) - but for most everyday people aka. those who don't read comics, the movies ARE synonymous with DC.

I though I explained that well? Perhaps I wasn't clear enough. :(

Edited 2015-07-11 23:35 (UTC)

well i'm glad i was correct in my explanation! i wasn't 100% sure because sometimes it just seemed like it was talking about your opinion about the movies - not generalizing to the rest of the audience. maybe that's what dethtoll thought, idk.

I was talking about my opinion and (likely) the opinion of many people who've only seen the movies (like me).

they don't have any exposure to or knowledge of the recent comics.

No fucking shit? You're not telling me anything I'm not aware of, I'm saying none of that matters. Not even the comics really matters. All that matters is that DC's movies should not reflect on DC as a whole because WB can't make a superhero movie. That. Is. It. That's all I'm trying to say. I was trying to be fucking HELPFUL and also defend something that matters to me.

All you're doing is saying it's okay to not listen to someone who actually knows what they're talking about and is trying to provide some context so you can keep your precious misconceptions. And it's like, that's fine, but at least TELL me you're not interested in listening so I can spend my time more wisely.

Edited 2015-07-12 02:28 (UTC)

but kaijin was saying that your context doesn't matter because it doesn't have anything to do with her xontext. you are just droning on about how DC isn't really like what her opinion is. but her opinion is based off something other than yours.

It has EVERYTHING to do with her context. Of course she thinks all of DC is grimdark, because she's only ever seen the movies. That is a misconception. I just wanted to correct that misconception like any fan of something would. Is that so fucking wrong?

Kaijin is correct in saying that the DC movies are grimdark, though.

The question, ultimately, is this: are the DC comics higher or more legitimate or 'realer' in status than the DC movies or the DC animated series? And I think there's reasonable answers on both sides.

Kaijin is correct in saying that the DC movies are grimdark, though.

I'm not disputing that! I never disputed that! I even acknowledged that elsewhere in this thread! They're so fucking po-faced, I actually partially blame them for the majority of media aimed at males 18-34 being serious as a heart attack with an emphasis on "gritty realism" while being dull as dishwater. This was never actually a matter of debate.

What I am saying (once again) is the movies are made by WB (and more to the point, written by David Goyer,) not DC themselves. DC might be peripherally involved, it might be DC characters, but DC staff do not really have a major role in the development of these films and how they are marketed -- that's all WB's doing, and it's largely WB mandate that drives the overly serious tone to a lot of the licensed material like the movies and games.

The question, ultimately, is this: are the DC comics higher or more legitimate or 'realer' in status than the DC movies or the DC animated series? And I think there's reasonable answers on both sides.

That's a pretty loaded question.

In the long run, the comics are important -- after all, without them and the characters created for them, we wouldn't have any of the movies or cartoons or games or whatever. But they're not that important. What's important is not tarring the entirety of DC -- comics, licensed material, etc. -- with the same brush because WB doesn't know how to make a superhero film, keeps hiring the same shitty writer and director, and utterly disregards Marvel's formula for a successful movie franchise. I'd say the same thing about the Arkham games and their problem with sexism, which I'm pretty sure is mostly due to Rocksteady as a different studio did Arkham Origins and that was much less problematic.

It's completely understandable for someone to look at the movies and think, "Oh, DC is just so dull and stone-faced and grim." If I didn't know the first thing about comics, I'd think the same way. But it's wrong. All I am trying to do is say, "please don't disregard DC as a whole just because their movies are crap." Kaijin doesn't have to read the comics. She doesn't have to play the games. She doesn't have to do any of that shit. All I'm asking is that she -- and others -- please take into account that the primary problem with the movies is WB, not DC.

I really don't understand why it's okay to defend a fandom and correct misconceptions except when it's DC.

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

(frozen comment) Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

(frozen comment) Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

(frozen comment) Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

(frozen comment) OMG NO

(frozen comment) Re: OMG NO

(frozen comment) Re: OMG NO

(frozen comment) Re: OMG NO

(frozen comment) Re: OMG NO

(frozen comment) Re: OMG NO

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER

Re: BATSUPE TRAILER