(no subject)

[case]

"I wanted to suggest that there could be a separate comment thread for each secret, but someone already suggested it and there was a concern about loading times.

I would rather bear the longer loading times for separate comment threads for each secret than painstakingly search for responses to specific secrets on each page of comments (and then going back to look if anyone's responded since last check).

There are other benefits as well:
- Questions about a specific secret (Eg. What episode is this secret from?) can be answered once for everyone without being repeatedly asked and answered over the course of 10+ pages.
- It could encourage people to comment on a secret that doesn't have any comments yet.
- It would save the Ctrl and F buttons of keyboards everywhere.

Could there at least be a poll about this suggestion please?"

[Poll #1377886]

Comments

[ook.livejournal.com]

THIS! People would have to waste a lot of time, trying to find the sub-threads to post in.

Part of the fun is searching for comments, but I do wish that people would simply list the (often obscure) fandom, episode, title, character names, at the bottom of their damn secret! (as part of the secret image). IMO, fandom!secrets should be about a person's secret desires, not playing "Let's Guess The Obscure Fandom."

[hiidenuhma.livejournal.com]

Thirded. It's a nice idea, but the time saved in not having to look for specific comments would be lost in posting comments to a bunch of different threads. I bet people who usually comment on many secrets would tone it down if this suggestion becomes regular service.

The chaos in the comments is part of the fun, no need to make everything so organized. :/

[bamf-girl.livejournal.com]

"Let's Guess the Obscure Fandom" is a game that frequently pisses me off. XP "Boo hoo, no one is in my fandom!" cries the secret, but I notice you failed to add what fandom it is or how to get at it! Thanks, you elitist cock!