[ SECRET POST #4748 ]

[case]

⌈ Secret Post #4748 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.

01.



__________________________________________________



02.


__________________________________________________



03.


__________________________________________________



04.


__________________________________________________



05.


__________________________________________________



06.


__________________________________________________



07.


__________________________________________________



08.















Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 02 pages, 41 secrets from Secret Submission Post #680.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

your concern for trans people is so obviously sincere and real, it's touching

[(Anonymous)]

My concern is for the rest of the lgbt community they’re hurting.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2019/06/24/lgbtq-acceptance-millennials-decline-glaad-survey/1503758001/

[(Anonymous)]

Lol, so your avowed point of view is that trans people must be sacrificed on the altar of respectability?

[(Anonymous)]

I’m saying pick your battles. Go after Trump and the Republicans who are actively hurting trans people, not a beloved children’s author.

[(Anonymous)]

There was a minor flurry of chatter two weeks ago and everyone who's not on f!s moved on.

[(Anonymous)]

Criticizing JK Rowling for open transphobia in no way precludes opposing Donald Trump.

[(Anonymous)]

Sounds a whole lot like you're saying the feelings of trans people don't matter and that they should pick the battles YOU want to fight.

And do you really think there are people who are choosing to criticize JKR while... ignoring politicians who are actively harming them? Do you not understand people fighting more than one battle at once? Because I'm picking fucking all of them.

Did I grow up loving Harry Potter? Sure. My sister introduced me to the books when we were young. My family bonded over reading the books together and waiting for the later ones to be released, we went to a midnight book release party together for the last one. Had a lot of fun. Poured who knows how many hours into drawing the characters, taking sorting and patronus quizzes, sharing fan theories and thoughts on ships...

But my sister and I are both trans, and our lives and our dignity are worth more than a slavish devotion to someone who once wrote a thing we cared about.

I mean, I'm a fan of the works of HP Lovecraft and he was also a garbage person who believed awful, hateful things. It's possible to love a book or a series, and be nostalgic about the place it had in your life, and still be critical of the author when they spread harmful speech. This wasn't an innocent mistake, this wasn't the first time JKR has liked TERF rhetoric, this is just the point at which even people who hadn't previously been following closely enough to be disappointed had to face the conversation.


And by the way, it's not up to you to say what 'actively' hurts trans people-- because seeing a beloved children's author give voice to our enemies DOES hurt us. And being told to sit down and shut up hurts us further. We're not the ones dividing the community-- you are, when you ask us to sit on our feelings for your comfort.

[(Anonymous)]

+1000000

[(Anonymous)]

Singling JKR, arguably the most famous author in the world is exactly the battle trans people should fight since she is such a high profile person. Attacking her draws way more attention than even going after Trump at this point because everybody attacks that guy for everything. But JKR's still on a pedestal so people are more likely to take what she says seriously.

[(Anonymous)]

People aren’t going to choose you over her.

[(Anonymous)]

Ah, so it's APPEASEMENT you want. Okay. Let's all just pretend we're not gay, then all the homophobes will be happy, too.

Quit using my sexuality for your bashing of trans people. It's disgusting and makes you subhuman.

[(Anonymous)]

if you want more people to turn against you.

[(Anonymous)]

It's disgusting and makes you subhuman.

Wow, no. That is a truly hypocritical and inane opinion to have. It's also just not correct.

[(Anonymous)]

You know, the idea that anyone has to "choose" is a classic example of fandom stupid.

[(Anonymous)]

LOL I will choose the living, breathing humans over a fictional world, every single time. What's wrong with you?

[(Anonymous)]

Your source here doesn't say anything about it being the meanie trans's fault, genius. How about instead of blaming other marginalized people within our community (you do know what the T in LGBT stands for, right), you aim your bullshit at the people who ARE actually hurting us?

[(Anonymous)]

When people like Jessica yaniv are all over the news, and South Park satirizes trans athletes as men beating up women, it’s an educated guess they’re the ones getting the most backlash.

[(Anonymous)]

And your considered opinion is that the best and most moral course of action is to knuckle under to the backlash?

[(Anonymous)]

It’s to not make it worse.

[(Anonymous)]

So, yes, knuckle under the backlash, and say "thank you, may i have another" when our community gets shit on? Great idea.

[(Anonymous)]

Rowling was hardly “shitting” on the community, and if you force people to choose between you and her you’re going to lose.

[(Anonymous)]

Wow, a niche case that's hardly "all over the news" and fucking SOUTH PARK back up your argument? Amaaaazing. You're right. Better dump a part of our community that has been there since the very beginning.

[(Anonymous)]

The whole issue with trans women athletes beating cis women is still a big controversy

[(Anonymous)]

Because people are transphobes.

[(Anonymous)]

Women athletes in general have been subjected to unfair and frankly bullshit restrictions and testing for decades that male athletes aren't. I'm more worried about that than the infinitesimally small amount of trans women athletes who just want to compete.