[ SECRET POST #6120 ]

[case]

⌈ Secret Post #6120 ⌋

Warning: Some secrets are NOT worksafe and may contain SPOILERS.


01.



__________________________________________________



02.



__________________________________________________



03.



__________________________________________________



04.



__________________________________________________



05.



__________________________________________________



06.



__________________________________________________



07.



__________________________________________________



08.

























Notes:

Secrets Left to Post: 02 pages, 41 secrets from Secret Submission Post #875.
Secrets Not Posted: [ 0 - broken links ], [ 0 - not!secrets ], [ 0 - not!fandom ], [ 0 - too big ], [ 0 - repeat ].
Current Secret Submissions Post: here.
Suggestions, comments, and concerns should go here.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

OP: The dancing was humorous since it was the main character celebrating something. You would expect a gif of the same character hugging another to meant well, but...

[(Anonymous)]

I think it’s because you left out the celebrating part in your secret that not everyone is seeing what’s wrong beyond you didn’t like it. As it’s written, your secret makes you sound like an asshole. With the added context, the other person is an asshole and it’s shocking and awful that happened to you :(

[(Anonymous)]

Not OP but

As it’s written, your secret makes you sound like an asshole.

No. No, it doesn't.

[(Anonymous)]

Yeah it does

[(Anonymous)]

Seconding it, it kinda does.

[(Anonymous)]

It really doesn't.

[(Anonymous)]

No, not even a little. I am very sorry if this is how some people are learning that sending a cute fandom gif is an inappropriate response to finding out a friend has suffered a traumatic experience. But that’s the fault of whoever was responsible for socializing them properly, and not the fault of the grieving person dealing with their insensitivity.

[(Anonymous)]

Fucking amen.

[(Anonymous)]

This comment is interesting, because it acknowledges that responses to grief are socially constructed, while at the same time implying that there's only one correct way to respond to it, and everyone who comes from a place where it's done differently has something wrong with them.

[(Anonymous)]

OP: Why it makes me sound like an asshole? I thought it was common sense that to someone dealing with grief the best thing to say/do is "I'm sorry for your loss", "Sending you my condolences" and all these stuff, not posting a character dancing, even if it wasn't in a humorous situation.

[(Anonymous)]

Yeah how fucking date they try to connect with you through your shared interest instead of an empty platitude!

Seriously the gif was wildly inappropriate and insensitive but you left that part out of the secret. You said dancing, not celebrating. Not all dancing is celebrating, most dancing isn’t celebrating. Your feelings are valid regardless but you wrote a secret making someone else out to be an asshole without the key information necessary for everyone to know why they’re an asshole. So not everyone agreed with you.

[(Anonymous)]

Not OP

You did this to someone, didn't you? It's the only reason I can think of that you would be *this* vitriolic about it.

[(Anonymous)]

+1 Sounds like someone who did something insensitive and dumb in response to another person's grief and now they're upset that other people noticed.

[(Anonymous)]

The secret (as written) is “Someone made a heartfelt gesture with good intentions that I didn’t appreciate and I harbor so much resentment about it that I’ve let it spoil that fandom to the point I don’t like the canon anymore.” That honestly sounds like an asshole to me.
But knowing that the REAL story is “Someone posted something wildly inappropriate during a dark time for me and even when confronted they didn’t acknowledge the additional hurt they caused me” makes the fandom rando the asshole, not OP.

So yeah, context matters here. Which was the entire point of the comment that kicked off this thread. It sucks that that happened to OP but not everyone in the secret thread really got that because OP left out all the most important information.

[(Anonymous)]

My parents are dead. One of them died in front of me, while I literally felt her pulse fade. I hated, absolutely hated, the empty, pitying rounds of "sorry for your loss" that I was treated to. It did not make me feel any fucking better! It made me feel like I was being patted on the head and then sent on my way, because it's not like anyone actually wanted to hear about what I was feeling. You clearly would have joined in on that, but I wouldn't have decided that you were some sort of awful person for it, any more than I thought it of anyone else. I know they were uncomfortable, and they meant well, and were doing their best.

This thread is so maddening. It's everyone assuming that because they either experience or think they'll experience grief in the way that's socially acceptable in our culture, it's how everyone else is going to experience it. And then deciding that anyone who has learned to approach grief in a different way, possibly through direct experience, is somehow awful. But how many people have all of you inadvertently hurt, by assuming that following the script will give them what they need?

[(Anonymous)]

nayrt

Are you okay, anon?

You seem... awfully invested for someone not involved in the exchange.

[(Anonymous)]

OP: I can see the point and I do agree with you, but then again, I said that person didn't saw their mistake in realizing the post wasn't one to post a dancing gif in general, nor giving apologies or excuses. It would have been different in a post about a celebration or a happy news, not about someone's death.

[(Anonymous)]

da but they probably didn't "see their mistake" because they genuinely thought they were trying to be supportive...?

[(Anonymous)]

It's amazing the mental gymnastics you're performing to try and make this OP's fault. If you're sincere and not just trolling... your ability to read the room needs big time tweaking.

[(Anonymous)]

it's not op's fault but they're being unnecessarily vicious towards someone who was clearly trying to do something nice. if the person didn't care about wanting to try to make op feel better, they would just have scrolled past the post and not responded at all. it may not have been a helpful response but the fact that they took the time to make an effort should count for something.

[(Anonymous)]

Why is everyone here so fucking smug?

[(Anonymous)]

Give me one example where a gif of someone dancing would be at all appropriate as a response.

Or, further, even if it WAS an emotionally-appropriate gif, not everyone wants their comfort show to be directly associated with a real life event. I would have had the same response as OP--don't make me have to think about the real grief when I'm trying to escape

[(Anonymous)]

YMMV. Personally I find platitudes kind of awful when I'm grieving, even though I realize people say them with the best of intentions, so I would honestly rather get a happy gif of a character I like dancing. Everyone deals with grief differently.

[(Anonymous)]

The secret definitely doesn't make OP sound like an asshole. Your reading is way off.

[(Anonymous)]

OH okay wow yeah. The 'celebrating' is missing information all right (I don't think you sounded unreasonable *without* that, by any means, but it really changes things!)

To me, a cute animal gif (from a show that has a cute animal in it or non-fandom) or, as you say, a hug gif would be one thing, but it's real easy to get tone-deaf with show gifs and that one is... that one is SO beyond.

I really hope you can find some enjoyment again-- of your original comfort show, or of a new comfort show that can be that for you now. And I am sorry for your loss, however long ago, and that it was magnified instead of eased.